Sugar Cookie Playdough Recipe

Sharing is caring!

This sugar cookie playdough started as a fun idea and turned into a family favorite. The kids pretend to bake cookies while the whole house smells like vanilla.

It’s soft, easy to make and holds up for days of rolling and cutting.

Ages 2 and up
Time 15 minutes
Smells like Sugar cookies
Keeps A few weeks, sealed

How to Make Sugar Cookie Playdough

Flat lay of sugar cookie playdough ingredients. Glass bowls hold flour, salt, cream of tartar, oil, and water. Two bottles of extract sit beside the bowls on a bright white background. Text reads “parentingchaos.com.”

Christmas Playdough Task Cards

Get the printable

2 cups flour

1 cup salt

2 tablespoons cream of tartar

1 1/2 cups warm water

2 tablespoons vegetable oil

1 tablespoon vanilla extract

View on Amazon

1/2 teaspoon butter extract

View on Amazon

Cookie cutters and a rolling pin

Some links above are affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Mix the dry ingredients

Stir the flour, salt and cream of tartar together in a large nonstick pan.

A glass mixing bowl filled with dry ingredients for sugar cookie playdough — flour and salt sitting side by side on a white background. Text reads “parentingchaos.com.”

Add the wet ingredients

Stir in the oil, vanilla, butter extract and warm water. It will look gloopy, which is just right.

A glass bowl showing sugar cookie playdough ingredients before mixing. Flour, oil, water, and vanilla extract are visible with small bubbles forming on the surface. Text reads “parentingchaos.com.”

Cook it

Stir over medium heat. It goes from runny to a thick paste to a soft dough in 3 to 5 minutes. It’s done when it pulls away from the pan in a ball.

A ball of freshly cooked sugar cookie playdough resting in a dark nonstick pan, soft and smooth in texture. Text reads “parentingchaos.com.”

Cool and knead

Let it cool until warm but comfortable, then knead until smooth. Add a little flour if it’s sticky.

A tan ball of sugar cookie playdough surrounded by blue snowflake cookie cutters, candy canes, and colorful gumdrops. Text reads “parentingchaos.com.”
A child’s hands press a blue snowflake cookie cutter into rolled-out sugar cookie playdough, surrounded by gumdrops and candy canes. Text reads “parentingchaos.com.”

Safety note

The dough is very hot right out of the pan, so a grown-up handles the cooking and checks it before kids knead. Homemade playdough is very salty and isn’t for eating, even when it smells like a treat. Keep it away from pets.

Sugar Cookie Playdough Tips

  • Storing it: Keep it in an airtight container or zip-top bag once completely cool. It lasts a few weeks.
  • Dried out? Knead in a few drops of water.
  • Pretend bakery: Add cookie cutters, a baking sheet and sprinkle-colored beads.
  • Want it colored? Add a few drops of food coloring with the wet ingredients.

Build Christmas trees and more with our Christmas Lego mats.

The Christmas task cards include

  • Holiday play dough task cards
  • Fine motor building challenges
  • Instant PDF download, nothing is shipped

Perfect for

  • December centers
  • Preschool and kindergarten
  • OT
  • Holiday parties

Sugar Cookie Playdough FAQ

How do you make sugar cookie playdough?

Cook a basic playdough with vanilla and butter extract until it pulls away from the pan, then cool and knead.

Is sugar cookie playdough edible?

No. It’s very salty and not for eating.

Can I add sprinkles?

Yes. Knead them in once the dough has cooled a bit.

How long does it last?

A few weeks in an airtight container.

From families like yours

Did you try it? Tell us how it went!

We love seeing these activities out in the wild: the lumpy letters, the snack breaks, the proud “I made a B!” moments. Leave a star rating, tell other parents what worked (and what totally didn’t), and add a photo of your setup if you’d like.

No stories yet. Be the first family to share how it went!

Stephanie Oswald, early childhood intervention specialist and creator of Parenting Chaos

Hi, I’m Stephanie!

I’m an early childhood intervention specialist and the mom behind Parenting Chaos. I share simple, hands-on activities that help little ones learn through play. Coffee addict, nature junkie and kid at heart.

More about me →

Sharing is caring!